Corn and Ethanol Win: Court Determines EPA Ignored Important Regulatory Comments

Lindsay Croke
June 26, 2025

Major Legal Win for Ethanol: Court Sides with Corn Growers Against EPA’s Flawed Fuel Rule

The Environmental Protection Agency has lost a Fifth Circuit court case brought by Texas Corn Producers and other industry groups, with the opinion finding that the agency used faulty methodology to justify a penalty to ethanol-blended fuel and ignored submitted comments. 

 

The case considered a 1975 EPA decision to set an R-Factor (a number that compares a vehicle's miles per gallon using today’s fuels with the miles per gallon that vehicle gets using the older certification fuel) of 0.6, which stood until 2020. Then, during a Tier 3 rulemaking on certification fuels, the EPA set an R-Factor of 0.81, a number not found in any of the peer-reviewed research on this topic and a number that cost automakers, ethanol producers, and corn farmers money and markets.

 

The ethanol industry, automakers, corn farmers, and researchers agree that an R-Factor of 1 (or 0.96) is most appropriate for a level playing field.

 

Brian West, West Energy and Environment, Joined ICGA In Submitting Comments That EPA Ignored

 

Mr. West has been consulting since he retired from Oak Ridge National Laboratory in 2019, where he published analysis that determined an R-Factor of 0.96. He said they gave EPA everything needed in 2013 to set the R value to 0.96 based on analysis of the 15% ethanol (E15) and E20 testing from the U.S. Department of Energy Mid-Level Blends program that led to the legalization of E15. 

 

West shared that anything less than 1.0 is harmful to the auto manufacturers if they use ethanol blends. He pointed to a large auto/oil test program in the early 1990s that determined R should be 0.93, but it remained at 0.6 until the 2020 Tier 3 decision that updated it to 0.81 based on EPA’s own very limited testing.

 

"With R set at 0.6, the auto manufacturers would be penalized for using E10, so they continued to use E0 for fuel economy testing," West said. "If we are ever to realize high-octane mid-level blends like E25 or E30, we have to have R set close to 1.0 so that the manufacturers can get full credit for building more efficient vehicles."

Quote about fuel efficiency, highlighting blends like E25 or E30 and setting

The Opinion of the Three-Judge Panel

 

Within the published opinion, the judges call the EPA’s defense “lipstick on a pig.”

 

The EPA themselves admitted, “Although [the Agency’s] explanations provide a sufficient basis for the Court to reasonably discern how and why EPA set the Ra Factor at 0.81, the Agency acknowledges that it did not fully respond to specific comments on the proposal.”

 

The opinion disagreed with that sentiment and points to several significant comments which would have necessitated a change in course, had the EPA fully considered them.

 

What’s Next?

 

While this is a big win for corn farmers and ethanol producers that will send EPA back to the drawing board, no one knows what their next published R-Factor could look like.

 

Experts wonder if they will again conduct their own testing program rather than acknowledging the data and research that already exists and is readily available from the U.S. Department of Energy, Oak Ridge National Laboratory.

 

Corn Associations Represent Corn Farmers

 

“This is a great example of why farmers should belong to their associations,” said Garrett Hawkins, President of IL Corn Growers Association and farmer from Waterloo, IL. “The R-Factor issue is a complicated one that I bet 99% of farmers don’t even know exists, but one that is keeping our cleaner-burning ethanol fuel from accessing the marketplace. I’m proud of the work of our partner organization, Texas Corn Producers, and I’m proud of the support ICGA provided to our Texas neighbors to challenge this EPA decision.”

 

ICGA will continue to represent Illinois corn farmers as the R-Factor determinations progress, and in any policy or regulatory environment to boost demand for corn-based ethanol.

Golden sunset over a broad green field, with farm buildings and a lone tree along the distant horizon.
By Lyndi Allen • November 19, 2026
ICGA is requesting federal oversight, competitive rates, and reliable service as Union Pacific and Norfolk Southern pursue a merger that could affect Illinois farmers and grain transportation.
Nathan Dwyer in front of large farm display
By Tara Desmond • November 19, 2026
Illinois farm kid Nathan Dwyer built a 1/64-scale field tiling and farm construction display for the National Farm Toy Show. Read about his build.
field corn ears
By Tara Desmond and Brownfield Ag • November 19, 2026
U.S. Grains Council & BioProduct’s Mark Sevier explains how IL Corn checkoff dollars help prove U.S. corn’s value to buyers in Mexico, Latin America and beyond.
group at pork power event
By Tara Desmond • November 18, 2026
IL Corn joins Pork Power partners to deliver pork to Eastern Illinois Foodbank, part of 101,000+ pounds donated to Illinois food banks this year.
IL Corn and Agriculture Organization Partners
By Lyndi Allen • November 18, 2026
IL Corn joined agricultural partners at the Latino Caucus Gala to celebrate Latino contributions to Illinois agriculture and build relationships with state and federal leaders.
John Klemm and Dale Haudrich Receive Award
By Lindsay Croke • November 17, 2026
As USMEF marks its 50th anniversary, its impact serves as a reminder that export development is not just about selling more product overseas. It is about building long-term demand, creating value throughout the supply chain, and generating returns for farmers at home. *Based on an average corn price of $4.29 per bushel and 2025 beef and pork export data.
Show More