Are Pesticides the Primary Cause of Species Decline in North America?

Popular culture suggests as much; however, a systematic review of the evidence indicates otherwise. A recent publication evaluated the primary, secondary, tertiary, quaternary, and quinary contributors to terrestrial plant decline in the United States and Canada based primarily on U.S. Fish and Wildlife (USFWS) recovery plans for 938 “listed” (threatened and endangered) species, as well as 206 species listed as being of special concern by the Government of Canada.

What was the primary driver you ask? Wait for it…invasive species, accounting for ~43% of the total in the U.S., followed by habitat alteration (~26%) and development (~23%). In Canada, habitat alteration was the primary driver, followed by development and non-native species. But what about pesticides? Herbicides or insecticides were identified as the primary or secondary driver of decline for a total of 12 listed plants species in the U.S. (~1.3%) and 2 species in Canada (~1%).

Herbicides, insecticides, or pesticides were identified as a driver of any importance (primary to quinary) for a total of 46 listed plant species in the U.S. and 10 species in Canada. Clearly, factors other than the application of pesticides pose much greater risks to the health and viability of listed plant species. This analysis is part of a four-publication series intended to provide context regarding the dominant causal factors influencing species decline in North America.

Context matters. Pesticides have a contentious origin, plausible biological relevance, and an easily exploited legal construct in the U.S. (e.g., citizen suit provisions) making them an easy target for litigious opportunism. However, being an easy target does not mean pesticides are the right target. Granted, it is difficult to sue the Spanish conquistador Hernando de Soto for having introduced feral hogs to Florida in 1539 for example, or John Rolfe for introducing a new variety of tobacco in1612, or Mother Nature for pathogen outbreaks, droughts, and floods.

The unintended consequences of promoting a narrative and sensationalizing a micro-scale contributor to a macro-scale issue include lack of public awareness regarding the primary drivers of species decline, missed opportunity to proactively address them, and potential misallocation of resources. In effect, metaphorically, we will miss the conservation opportunity of the forest for the counterfactual narrative of the trees.

Many thanks to my co-authors Julie Anderson and Ryan Prosser for realizing these analyses over the past several years and Daniel Perkins for creating the artwork.

< Older Post

Newer Post >

Hear from Lou Lamoreux: Livestock Farmer and Former IL Corn Board Director

By Tara Desmond • September 3, 2026

Livestock farmer Lou Lamoreux talks about his farming operation.

captain Cornelius at shake it up cocktail lounge

Cheers to Corn This Labor Day

By Tara Desmond • September 3, 2026

4.29M bushels of U.S. corn fueled beverage alcohol production in July 2026 alone — up 54% from July 2025. Corn's in your Labor Day toast!

Can Short Stature Corn Deliver? Steve Fourez Puts It to the Test

By Tara Desmond • September 3, 2026

Illinois farmer Steve Fourez tests short stature corn against conventional hybrids, exploring yield potential and late-season management benefits.

USDA Announces Plans to Modernize Agricultural Data Collection

By Lyndi Allen • September 3, 2026

This week, U.S. Secretary of Agriculture Brooke L. Rollins announced the U.S. Department of Agriculture (USDA) Data Modernization Plan to put Farmers First, reduce unnecessary burdens on producers, and improve the timeliness, accuracy, and usefulness of the data that informs agricultural decisions. USDA data informs crop and livestock estimates, risk-management tools, disaster assistance, and critical business decisions made by farmers, ranchers, agribusinesses, researchers, and policymakers. In February 2026, Secretary Rollins issued a Request for Information seeking feedback on the opportunities, challenges, and emerging areas in USDA data. That feedback helped shape the USDA Data Modernization Plan and its four pillars: Modernize the Data Reporting Experience: USDA will expand use of administrative data, improve mobile access to surveys, explore opportunities to use prefilled information where appropriate, and strengthen coordination across the Department. These changes will reduce duplicative requests and limit the amount of time producers spend reporting information. Enhance Acreage and Yield Estimation: USDA will conduct a pilot to evaluate the use of improved satellite imagery, geospatial tools, crop models, and other emerging technologies combined with essential producer-reported information to enhance acreage and yield estimations. USDA will also assess the use of optional field inputs to enhance and ground truth yield estimates and continue advancing yield research through collaboration with agricultural partners and land-grant universities. Integrate Data and Technology Platforms: USDA will modernize its technology infrastructure, expand secure data-sharing capabilities, and evaluate the responsible use of tools such as artificial intelligence and machine learning. Better integrated systems will improve efficiency, reduce duplication, and allow USDA to produce more timely and useful information. Expand Trust and Transparency with Producers: USDA will protect producer privacy, clearly explain why information is requested and how it is used, and create additional opportunities for producers to provide feedback. USDA will also improve communication surrounding reports, methodologies, response rates, and data limitations. USDA will begin implementing actions under the plan immediately and will continue engaging farmers, ranchers, and agricultural stakeholders throughout the process. The Department will evaluate new approaches carefully, protect privacy and confidentiality, and publish clear methodologies and supporting information to maintain the integrity of USDA’s agricultural statistics. See USDA’s Full Data Modernization Plan

Cornfield beside a dirt path under a blue sky with wispy clouds

EPA Grants Biofuel Exemptions

By Lyndi Allen • September 2, 2026

EPA has granted 1.76 billion RIN exemptions to small refiners, raising concerns among farmers and biofuel producers about the potential impact on demand for renewable fuel.

Week Ending 8/28/26 Summary

By Lyndi Allen • August 28, 2026

News from IL Corn for week ending 8/28/26