Are Pesticides the Primary Cause of Species Decline in North America?

August 8, 2024

Popular culture suggests as much; however, a systematic review of the evidence indicates otherwise. A recent publication evaluated the primary, secondary, tertiary, quaternary, and quinary contributors to terrestrial plant decline in the United States and Canada based primarily on U.S. Fish and Wildlife (USFWS) recovery plans for 938 “listed” (threatened and endangered) species, as well as 206 species listed as being of special concern by the Government of Canada.

What was the primary driver you ask?
 Wait for it…invasive species, accounting for ~43% of the total in the U.S., followed by habitat alteration (~26%) and development (~23%). In Canada, habitat alteration was the primary driver, followed by development and non-native species. But what about pesticides? Herbicides or insecticides were identified as the primary or secondary driver of decline for a total of 12 listed plants species in the U.S. (~1.3%) and 2 species in Canada (~1%).

Herbicides, insecticides, or pesticides were identified as a driver of any importance (primary to quinary) for a total of 46 listed plant species in the U.S. and 10 species in Canada. Clearly, factors other than the application of pesticides pose much greater risks to the health and viability of listed plant species. This analysis is part of a four-publication series intended to provide context regarding the dominant causal factors influencing species decline in North America.


Context matters.
 Pesticides have a contentious origin, plausible biological relevance, and an easily exploited legal construct in the U.S. (e.g., citizen suit provisions) making them an easy target for litigious opportunism. However, being an easy target does not mean pesticides are the right target. Granted, it is difficult to sue the Spanish conquistador Hernando de Soto for having introduced feral hogs to Florida in 1539 for example, or John Rolfe for introducing a new variety of tobacco in1612, or Mother Nature for pathogen outbreaks, droughts, and floods.

 

The unintended consequences of promoting a narrative and sensationalizing a micro-scale contributor to a macro-scale issue include lack of public awareness regarding the primary drivers of species decline, missed opportunity to proactively address them, and potential misallocation of resources. In effect, metaphorically, we will miss the conservation opportunity of the forest for the counterfactual narrative of the trees.

 

Many thanks to my co-authors Julie Anderson and Ryan Prosser for realizing these analyses over the past several years and Daniel Perkins for creating the artwork.

The sun is setting behind the capitol building in washington d.c.
By Lyndi Allen July 3, 2025
Illinois corn farmers will be impacted by many provisions in the Budget Reconciliation Bill that passed in both chambers this week.
By Tara Desmond July 3, 2025
Mid-Year Highlights: IL Corn Top 10 Read Stories
A map of the world with arrows pointing to trade countries
By Lyndi Allen July 3, 2025
Trade plays a critical role in driving demand for U.S. corn—not only as grain or feed, but also as fuel.
Top Videos of 2025
By Tara Desmond July 2, 2025
Harvesting the Best: A Look at IL Corn’s Top 10 Videos of 2025
By Lindsay Croke June 30, 2025
When we think of Independence Day traditions, sweet corn on the cob is as iconic as fireworks and often even more central to the celebration. According to Instacart, purchases of sweet corn surge by 380% over the annual average heading into July 4th, outranking other grilling staples like baby back ribs and burgers. But corn's role in your Fourth of July celebration goes far beyond your plate. In Illinois alone, 8,300 acres of sweet corn are harvested annually, averaging 155 cwt per acre. That’s more than 128 million pounds of locally grown sweetness fueling summer cookouts across the state. And while sweet corn makes a big impression on the grill, most of Illinois’ corn crop isn’t sweet corn - it’s field corn. Less than 1% of the state’s crop is sweet corn, while the rest is used in products that are often invisible to consumers but vital to everyday life: fuel, packaging, fireworks, and even spirits.
The sun is setting behind the capitol building in washington d.c.
By Lyndi Allen June 27, 2025
From Springfield to D.C., lawmakers are listening, and Illinois corn farmers are leading the conversations.
Show More