American Craft Spirits Association Announces 2025 Heartland Whiskey Competition’s Four Farmer-Distiller Awards in Three Categories

American Craft Spirits Association
August 21, 2025

All other Heartland awards will be announced August 26

The American Craft Spirits Association (ACSA) today announced the recipients of the Farmer-Distiller program of the 2025 Heartland Whiskey Competition. Starlight Distillery in Borden, Indiana, claimed the prestigious Top Farmer-Distiller award—the competition's most challenging honor, determined by the highest average score across three judged spirits from a single qualifying distillery. To qualify as a farmer-distiller, participants must both own a distillery and operate a working farm.


“This was an impressive showing from corn farmers who own distilleries, showcasing their ability to produce top-tier products and develop high-quality grain for distilling – grain that benefits craft distillers across the board,” said Paul Hodgen, a corn farmer from Roachdale, Indiana, and Indiana Corn Marketing Council Board Member. “ICMC, together with other state checkoff organizations, is proud to sponsor this competition to raise awareness of the many uses of corn.”


The Farmer-Distiller: Best Bourbon resulted in a numerical tie, with two distilleries sharing the honor. Queens Reserve, a product of Wood Hat Spirits in Florence, Missouri scored identically to Bloody Butcher Bourbon, which is produced by Pathfinder Farm Distillery in Boonsboro, Maryland. Both distilleries will receive awards.


Farmer-Distiller: Beyond Bourbon goes to Tobacco Barn Distillery in Hollywood, Maryland, for its Maryland Bourbon Cream. Tobacco Barn previously earned Top Farmer-Distiller in 2023.


Numerous corn farmers throughout the U.S. own and operate craft distilleries and submitted approximately 40 percent of this year’s entries, demonstrating the strong connection between agriculture and craft spirits production.


“We are very pleased by the enthusiasm that farmer-distillers have shown for this competition along with other craft distillers,” stated Margie A.S. Lehrman, CEO of ACSA. “With corn state support we’re able to promote the craft spirits industry and the important role that agriculture has in producing excellent spirits. The communication and information sharing on farming practices specifically for distilling is of great value to our members.”


The 2025 competition marked the fifth biennial Heartland Whiskey Competition, open to craft whiskeys incorporating corn in their mash bill. This blind-judging competition is generously sponsored by state corn marketing associations and ACSA facilitates the judging process. Former ACSA Board President Chris Montana, owner of Du Nord Social Spirits in Minnesota, served as Judging Director for the fifth time. Judges are selected from the spirits industry by ACSA and chosen for their knowledge of craft whiskey.


All other Heartland Whiskey Competition awards will be announced August 26.


Scoring and Medal Criteria

The scoring of whiskeys, with judges hand-selected from the North American spirits community, was based on a 100-point system with 10 main categories of consideration: Appearance (10 points), Aroma Intensity (10 points), Aroma Complexity (10 points), Palate Concentration (10 points), Palate Complexity (10 points), Body (10 points), Alcohol (10 points), Texture (10 points), Finish (10 points), and Pour for a Peer (10 points).


Whiskeys were then assigned a medal based on the average score determined by the following benchmarks: 70-79 = Bronze; 80-89 = Silver; 90-100 = Gold.


Best Farmer-Distiller was awarded to the top average score across three spirits among all judged whiskeys submitted by Famer-Distillers. Farmer-Distiller: Best Bourbon and Farmer-Distillery Beyond Bourbon were awarded to the spirits that scored highest in the bourbon category and all other categories respectively.


About ACSA

The American Craft Spirits Association is the only national registered nonprofit trade association representing the U.S. craft spirits industry. Its mission is to elevate and advocate for the community of craft spirits producers, and membership in ACSA is open to anyone. ACSA is governed by a Board of Directors elected by the eligible voting members of the Association. Voting members must be independent, licensed distillers (DSPs) annually removing fewer than 750,000 proof gallons from bond (the amount on which a Federal Excise Tax is paid).

staff at Topflight
By Tara Desmond March 12, 2026
Meet Julie Day in our Inside the Elevator series as she shares her journey to TopFlight Grain and what it takes to handle 42 million bushels during harvest.
Clint
By Tara Desmond & Clint Gorden March 12, 2026
Illinois farmer Clint Gorden shares how using wheat as both a cover crop and cash crop helps improve soil health, support wildlife and still make conservation pay.
AI on the farm
By Tara Desmond March 12, 2026
AI is transforming agriculture from autonomous tractors to crop AI tools but farmers remain essential to the future of ag.
Kate Pink Hat Farmer
By Tara Desmond March 12, 2026
For the woman known online as the Pink Hat Farmer , the road back to the family farm wasn’t always obvious. A sixth-generation farmer from Galva and Kewanee, Illinois, she grew up surrounded by agriculture but also the realities that come with it. As a child, she watched her family navigate difficult times in the industry, including the stress of the 1990s hog crisis. Seeing that pressure firsthand made her question whether farming was the life she wanted. After graduating from the University of Illinois, she moved to the Chicago suburbs and tried building a life away from agriculture. But it didn’t take long to realize something was missing. “I lasted nine months,” she says. “I love to visit my friends up there. But that lifestyle wasn’t for me.” What she missed most was the rhythm of farm life - being able to step outside, work on a piece of machinery, and reset her mindset in the quiet of the countryside. Eventually, the pull of the farm proved stronger than the push to stay away. Today she farms the same land her family has cared for for generations which she doesn’t take lightly. Her farm is recognized as a sesquicentennial farm , meaning it has remained in the same family for more than 150 years. In an era when many farms don’t make it past the third or fourth generation, reaching a sixth generation is a remarkable accomplishment. The name “Pink Hat Farmer” started almost by accident. One day, someone spotted her in a grocery store and shouted across the aisle, “Hey, Pink Hat Farmer!” The nickname stuck. What began as a joke has grown into a recognizable brand across multiple social media platforms. Through those platforms, she shares everyday farm life while also highlighting something close to her heart: the role of women in agriculture. Her mission is intentional. Everything connected to the Pink Hat Farmer from website design to merchandise and even artwork is created in partnership with women in agriculture. “Women have always been involved in farming,” she explains. “For generations, they were often behind the scenes. Now we’re starting to see more recognition.” By sharing her story, she hopes people outside of agriculture better understand the realities of farming and the people behind it. She’s also learned that telling those stories publicly comes with both encouragement and criticism. But the positive messages still stand out. “You might hear ten negative things before one compliment,” she says. “But when you get that one good one, remember it.” For the Pink Hat Farmer, the goal isn’t just growing crops. It’s growing understanding and helping the next generation see that there’s a place for them in agriculture too.
thumbnail of IL Corn TV
By Tara Desmond March 10, 2026
Illinois agriculture drives jobs, exports and innovation. Learn how the industry supports the state’s economy and future growth opportunities.
Greg Goodwin headshot
By Tara Desmond March 5, 2026
The Illinois Sustainable Ag Partnership is a collaborative network of organizations working together to advance sustainable agriculture across the state.
Show More