What Does a Cover Crop’s Carbon Really Cost? New PCM Data Puts a Number on It


By Summary from PCM / Farmdoc Webinar • October 8, 2026

Farmers hear about new conservation payment programs every year, offering payments for cover crops, reduced tillage, nitrogen management and other conservation practices. Payment levels for these practices vary widely and are usually made in exchange for ability to claim or, at minimum, to quantify an environmental asset, like reduction in greenhouse gas emissions or improvements to water quality, which are addressed with the practice. What has been harder to pin down is what it costs the farmer to provide these environmental benefits. A recent farmdoc webinar used field-level data from IL Corn’s Precision Conservation Management (PCM) program to answer that question.


Dr. Laura Gentry, Director of Water Quality Science at IL Corn, and Dr. Saurav Raj Kunwar, an agricultural economist at Texas Tech University, presented the findings of a University of Illinois-led economic analysis that was recently published in the Journal of American Agricultural Economics.


The traditional view

Gentry opened the webinar by describing the way PCM has historically reported cover crop economics to farmers. Averaged across the PCM dataset representing 11 years and nearly 10,000 corn field-years from high-productivity Illinois soils, the average operator and land return was:

  • $341 per acre for fields without a cover crop
  • $319 for winter-terminal cover crops
  • $305 for overwintering cover crops


Most of the gap in operator and land return between cover cropped and non-cover cropped corn fields comes from slightly lower yields for cover cropped fields, along with added direct and machinery costs. The environmental benefits were also clear. Cover-cropped fields lost roughly half a ton less soil per acre and showed meaningful reductions in net greenhouse gas emissions.

data from illinois fields on cover crops

A sharper measure

The new approach and results presented in the webinar utilize a mathematical programming analysis which treats cover crops as a technology the farmer pays for and asks a direct question: what is the minimum payment a farmer would need to provide carbon services and be no worse off?


Using 2021 data from 793 Illinois corn fields, the researchers put that cost at $27.30 per acre. The data came from 159 growers across 46 counties and about 51,700 acres. The total breaks into two parts:

  • $17.88 for storing additional soil carbon. Cover-cropped fields already stored far more carbon than other fields, 0.55 versus 0.12 tons CO₂e per acre. Each additional gain in soil carbon therefore requires more costly management changes.
  • $9.42 for reducing greenhouse gas emissions. A critical factor determining greenhouse gas emissions from agricultural fields is nitrogen fertilizer application rates. Cover cropped fields applied lower total nitrogen fertilizer rates than non-cover cropped fields, with a median of 195 lb versus 207 lb.


The data also confirmed a pattern PCM has seen for years. About 86% of cover-cropped fields also used conservation tillage, compared with about 70% of all non-cover cropped fields.


How payments stack up

Gentry compared the estimate with real programs:


Gentry noted that farmers may reasonably carry some of the cost themselves, because healthier soil increases the long-term value and productivity of their own land. On rented ground, she said, the farmer and landowner should discuss how to share that cost.


The fine print

Kunwar stressed the limits of the estimate. It covers one year and one crop, and it represents less than 1% of Illinois acres. It also captures only the farmer’s private cost for carbon services. The value of reduced erosion, better soil structure and lower nutrient loss is not included.


The method itself can be applied to other crops, practices, environmental assets, states and years. Valuing those additional benefits is a logical next step, and that work could help shape how future conservation incentives are designed.


Watch full webinar.  American Journal of Agricultural Economics Journal

maximum return to nitrogen rate

Not a member?

Become one today!

SHARE THIS

Latest Posts

John Klemm and Dale Haudrich Receive Award
By Lindsay Croke • November 17, 2026
In 2025, beef and pork exports accounted for 70.31 million bushels of Illinois corn usage, demonstrating the value of a system that promotes U.S. red meat around the world. By creating demand for beef and pork exports, often by marketing underutilized cuts and maximizing value of the entire animal, the U.S. Meat Export Federation (USMEF) helps strengthen markets for livestock and corn farmers alike. This year, USMEF celebrates its 50th anniversary. As a longtime partner of the Illinois Corn checkoff, the organization continues to play a critical role in expanding global opportunities for U.S. agriculture. During the USMEF Strategic Planning Conference and 50th Anniversary Celebration, Illinois corn farmer leaders had the opportunity to reflect on five decades of export growth while exploring what the next 50 years could hold for the industry. Five Decades of Export Growth Since USMEF was founded in 1976, the U.S. pork and beef industries have experienced dramatic growth in production, efficiency, and export demand. The share of pork production exported has risen from just 3.3% in 1976 to 26.0% in 2025, while beef exports have increased from 0.5% to 10.3% of total production. At the same time, production levels and animal weights have climbed, creating greater demand for corn. Perhaps most impressive is the value of exports. Since 2010, the export value of U.S. beef and variety meats has increased 129%, while the export value of U.S. pork and variety meats has climbed 76%.
Lindsay and Rachel thumbnail
By Tara Desmond • November 16, 2026
Would you know if a farmer you care about was quietly struggling? Farm SOS counselor Rachel Brown shares the warning signs.
thumbnail of Lindsay and Brooke
By Tara Desmond • November 12, 2026
NCERC research fellow Brooke Wagner shares how IL Corn-funded research at SIUE is creating new uses for Illinois corn. Watch on IL Corn TV.
thumbnail of Collin and Jared on Brownfield Ag
By Tara Desmond & Brownfield Ag • November 12, 2026
IL Corn’s Collin Watters tells Brownfield how trade team visits, ethanol demand and USMCA help move Illinois corn to markets worldwide.
U.S. Capitol building under a blue sky with dramatic clouds in Washington, D.C.
By Lyndi Allen • November 12, 2026
Congress returns to Washington, D.C. this week, with several unfinished legislative priorities that remain important to Illinois corn farmers and the future of agriculture.
Joe Hampton with Queen Johnna Fulcher
By Tara Desmond • November 11, 2026
Farmer, family man and founding IL Corn board member, Joe Hampton helped give farmers a seat at the table. His influence is still felt decades later.
Illinois Leopold Conservation Award: seeking nominees, deadline February 15, 2027, over a grassy field path
By Sand County Foundation • November 10, 2026
Applications are now being accepted for the 2027 Illinois Leopold Conservation Award.
Doug with his kids farming
By Tara Desmond • November 10, 2026
Jacksonville farmer and ICGA member Doug Coop served 20 years in the Army. Here's how service shaped his life, his family and his farm.
Four people posing in front of the U.S. Capitol at sunset
By Lyndi Allen • November 5, 2026
IL Corn's GrassRoots Orientation to Washington, D.C. program allows Illinois farmers and agricultural professionals to see firsthand how agricultural policy is shaped.
U.S. Capitol building at sunrise, viewed from a low angle with a yellow road line leading toward it
By Brad Stotler and Lyndi Allen • November 5, 2026
Illinois voters delivered decisive victories for Democrats across the state, expanding the party’s supermajorities in the General Assembly and electing a new U.S. Senator.
Show More